You pull up to show a listing. Your buyers are ready. Then another car pulls in behind you. The driver rolls down the window: "Hey—can I see this house too? My agent can't make it until Monday, but I know it'll be gone by then."
What do you do?
It's a scenario that happens more often than you'd think, and how you handle it determines whether you stay on the right side of ethics rules—and whether you waste time or earn a client.
You Can Let Them In (With the Right Paperwork)
If someone shows up and asks to see a house, you're allowed to help them. But you need to protect yourself first.
Before you unlock the door, ask a simple question: "Are you currently working with a real estate agent?"
If they say no, great. Have them sign a 24-hour showing agreement, show the house, and treat it like any other lead.
But if they say yes—even casually, like "Yeah, my cousin just got licensed" or "I have someone, but they're on vacation"—you need to be careful. Once a buyer tells you they're represented, you can't solicit their business. That's an ethics violation.
What You Can Say (and What You Can't)
If they tell you they already have an agent, here's the line:
"I'd be happy to let you in, but if you've signed a buyer agreement with another agent, I can't ethically show you the house unless you've ended that relationship or they've given you permission to work with someone else. If you'd like to cancel that agreement and work with me instead, I can help—but I can't step in while you're under contract with them."
You're not slamming their agent. You're not convincing them to leave. You're just being clear about the rules.
If they say, "I want to work with you—how do I get out of my agreement?" you can answer that question. What you can't do is pitch yourself while they're still under contract with someone else.
The Indirect Approach: Ask Better Questions First
Some agents don't lead with "Do you have an agent?" because they don't want to hear the wrong answer. Instead, they ask:
- "Is this the first house you've looked at?"
- "Where are you at in the process—just starting, or have you been out a few times?"
- "How long have you been searching?"
If they say, "Oh, we looked at three houses this morning," you know something's up. Now you can ask the follow-up: "Great—are you working with someone, or are you handling this on your own?"
That gives you room to build rapport first, understand their situation, and then figure out if they're available or already represented.
When It Turns Into a Client
One of our agents had exactly this scenario happen. A buyer showed up while he was showing a house to his own clients. He said, "Sure, I'll show you the house as soon as I'm done."
They talked for 20 minutes. She told him she liked his approach, that her current agent wasn't responsive, and that she wanted to switch. He didn't solicit her—he just answered her questions. She signed a buyer agreement later that day, and they closed a few weeks later.
That's the difference. He didn't recruit her. He helped her, built trust, and when she decided to make a change, he was ready.
If They're Just Using You to See the House
Here's the risk if you don't ask about representation: you show them the house, answer all their questions, spend 30 minutes walking the property—and then they say, "Thanks! I'm going to call my agent and put in an offer."
You just worked for free. And there's nothing you can do about it.
That's why most agents either ask up front or get a showing agreement signed before they unlock the door. It protects your time and sets a professional tone.
The Bottom Line
You can help an unrepresented buyer. You can even help a buyer who was represented, if they've ended that relationship and want to work with you instead.
What you can't do is recruit someone else's client, talk them out of their current agent, or ignore the fact that they're already under a buyer agreement.
Stay on the right side of the line. Be direct. And if they want to work with you, make sure the path is clear before you start.
FAQ
Can I show a house to someone who says they have an agent but that agent is unavailable?
Not unless they've canceled their agreement with that agent or the agent has given permission. If they're under a signed buyer agreement, showing them a property could be considered interference, even if their agent is out of town.
What's a 24-hour showing agreement, and when should I use one?
It's a short-term agreement that allows you to show a property to someone who isn't your client yet. It protects you from liability and establishes a professional relationship. Use it anytime you're showing a house to someone you haven't worked with before.
What if they say their cousin is an agent but they've never actually worked together?
Ask if they've signed anything. If they haven't signed a buyer agreement and the cousin hasn't shown them any houses, they're not represented. But tread carefully—family dynamics are tricky, and you don't want to create conflict. Be professional, not pushy.



