Cover: The Off-Market Pitch That Wins Over Buyers Already Working With Someone Else
buyer leads3 min read

The Off-Market Pitch That Wins Over Buyers Already Working With Someone Else

When a buyer says they're already working with an agent, don't try to out-argue them. Offer something their current agent isn't doing.

You call a buyer lead. They sound interested. Then they say it:

"We're already working with someone."

Most agents hear that and think the conversation is over. But if that buyer hasn't bought a house yet, there's a reason. And if you can solve that reason, the fact that they're "working with someone" stops mattering.

Here's the pitch that changes the game.

Why Haven't They Bought Yet?

If a buyer has been working with an agent for weeks—or months—and they still haven't found a home, one of two things is true:

  1. Nothing they want is available in their price range.
  2. They're seeing the same listings as everyone else, and losing every offer.

Either way, their current agent isn't solving the problem. So your job isn't to convince them you're better. Your job is to offer something their agent isn't doing.

The Off-Market Program Script

Here's how I'd handle it:

Buyer: "We're working with an agent already."

You: "That's great—I'm glad you have someone in your corner. Can I ask, what neighborhood are you focused on?"

Buyer: "We really want [Neighborhood Name], but everything's out of our budget or goes under contract in two days."

You: "I get it. Here's the thing—there are about 400 homes in [Neighborhood Name], and maybe 12 of them will sell this year. Most of those sellers haven't listed yet. So what I'm willing to do, if you're open to it, is run our off-market buyer program. I'll personally door-knock every home in that neighborhood, send a letter, make calls, and let people know I have a pre-approved buyer. If I can get you one of those 12 homes before it hits the market—and before you're competing with 10 other offers—would that be worth a conversation?"

Now you're not asking them to fire their friend. You're solving the problem their friend can't solve.

People Want What They Want

Here's the reality: buyers have all kinds of reasons they say they don't want to work with you. They're loyal to a friend. They're waiting for rates to drop. They're "just looking."

But if a $400,000 house gets listed tomorrow for $300,000 because an agent mis-priced it, every single one of those buyers is going to call.

It's not that they didn't want to buy. It's that the right opportunity hasn't shown up yet.

So your job is to create that opportunity. Find the unlisted home. Get the seller to buy down the rate. Offer the one thing no one else is offering.

The Ethical Line

One important note: if a buyer has signed an exclusive agreement with another agent, you can't solicit their business. That crosses the line.

But if they say, "I'm working with someone," and they haven't signed anything, you're allowed to have the conversation—especially if they reached out to you (on a lead portal, your website, a call-in, etc.).

You're not poaching. You're responding. And if they decide your off-market program is a better fit than waiting on auto-search emails, that's their call to make.

FAQ

Can I work with a buyer if they say they're already working with another agent?

It depends. If they've signed an exclusive buyer agreement, no. If they're just casually working with someone and haven't signed anything, yes—especially if they contacted you first.

What if the buyer says their agent is a friend?

Don't bad-mouth the friend. Instead, ask: "Would you be okay losing your dream home if it meant you could keep working with your friend?" That reframes the decision.

What's the best way to offer an off-market search?

Be specific. Tell them exactly what you'll do (door-knock, call, mail) and in what neighborhood. The more concrete your plan, the more real it feels—and the more likely they are to say yes.

buyer leadsoff marketscriptslead conversion
Dreams MadeReal.